how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers

You don't have to break the bank or get a lengthy auto loan to get a great car. 4 Why did Volkswagen profits fall in 2015? While the damage done to German firms has yet to be fully quantified across all markets and industries, research by my co-authors* and I suggests that, by virtue of their collective reputation, the German carmakers that played no part in the scandal lost sales worth billions of dollars in the United States alone. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. "It is turning out to be our Titanic," he said. Follow USA TODAY reporter Nathan Bomey on Twitter @NathanBomey. Given that the value of the car is frozen at its value just prior to the scandal breaking, some have suggested keeping your car right up to the deadline, according to a story by Green Car Reports. For example, the EPAs, using BenMAP recently estimated that one ton of on-road NOx can be expected to lead to. We're here to answer any questions you have about our services. According to a survey of more than 400 current TDI owners by car shopping site CarGurus.com, 21 percent say they will not buy another Volkswagen, though a surprising 43 percent say that they would. Almost 1.2m diesel vehicles in Britain are involved in the scandal, out of 11m worldwide, and VW faces a hefty bill if it is forced to make payouts to motorists. "Even before this happened, theyve been under-performing," AutoTrader.com analyst Michelle Krebs said. - In 2016 the group achieved its best results in history, 5.144 bn. That means that for the amount of NOx estimated from the Volkswagen scandal (10,000 to 40,000 tons), wed expect eight to 34 deaths. The cheating software means that the company's diesel cars are emitting harmful pollutants at rates of up to 40 times acceptable U.S. standards. Germany has had to face the impact of the Chinese slowdown and the Greece debt crisis, and due to its dependence on the automotive industry, and the scale and enormity of Volkswagen as an integral part of this industry, the country might face headwinds to its economic growth if car sales are significantly affected going forward. VW then admitted it had used engine software to rig results. I would say the power of "German engineering" still works for VW (and if you want to check numbers I would bet for other German manufacturers as well). Our ecosystem is fragile enough without the added consequences of corporate greed. Some consumers lost interest in diesel vehicles. The UK, Italy, France, South Korea, Canada and, of course, Germany, have opened investigations. We are talking millions of vehicles.". Specifically, they found that the overall effect on those manufacturers amounted to a decline in sales of 104,661 vehicles valued at $5.2 billion in 2016, based on the list prices in the data. VW knew of the problems with its vehicles. Volkswagen confesses to the Environmental Protection Agency and C.A.R.B. Since BMW and Mercedes-Benz continued to sell such vehicles after the scandal, this force was to their detriment. These vehicles are a smart choice for shoppers who want the efficiency of an EV but perhaps arent yet ready to fully commit. for only $13.00 $11.05/page. Richard Lloyd, the executive director of Which?, said: Many VW owners tell us they decided to buy their car based on its efficiency and low environmental impact, so its outrageous that VW arent being clear with their customers about how and when they will be compensated. Any cars that the company buys back must be rendered inoperable if they cannot be modified to meet standards, or if is not cost effective to do so. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy | CA Notice at Collection and Privacy Notice| Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information| Ad Choices While diesels accounted for around 25 percent of VWs sales before the scandal, sales for 2016 are only off 12.5 percent through September, according to VW. Offers may be subject to change without notice. This website is part of INSEAD Digital Ecosystem. Sales in the U.S. initially plummeted, as did the value of Volkswagens with diesel (TDI) engines. That's for the various regulatory and government inquiries to determine. With more than 480,000 cars affected, estimates have ranged from 10,000 to 40,000 tons of extra NOx released in the United States. Which? Any new vehicles would have to have expensive exhaust aftertreatment systems, and the mileage difference between diesels and gasoline hybrids is smaller than it once was. California Do Not Sell My Personal Information Request. What's more, consumer-sentimentsurveys suggestthat Volkswagen's image has suffered a serious blow. Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes. finds owners are worried about environmental impact of their vehicles and expect cash payouts. I think the customers are mainly trying to send a message to the company with this lawsuit. Its still possible to ride in style on even a modest budget thanks to these hard-to-beat luxury lease deals. "In the US, the diesel car market currently represents around 1% of all new car sales and this is unlikely to increase in the short to medium term. US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulations for diesel engines limit the amount of NOx that can be emitted per mile traveled. manufacturing defect. Altogether, we estimate that the VW scandal reduced the US sales of BMW, Mercedes-Benz and Smart the non-VW German carmakers present in the US by about 105,000 vehicles worth US$5.2 billion (based on the list prices), in the 12 months following the scandal that erupted in September 2015. 2023 BBC. In April, VW recorded its first annual loss in more than 20 years for 2015, after more than doubling the amount set aside to pay for costs related to the scandal to 16.2bn. How were the colonist able to beat the trained British soldiers? By contrast, negative Twitter sentiment spiked for VW post-scandal, consistent with the strong negative reaction that wrongdoing typically elicits. Our experts can deliver a customized essay. We found a decrease in consumers' taste for diesel vehicles. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. 2.0 liter diesel vehicle models and model years with defeat devices: Jetta (2009 2015) Jetta Sportwagen (2009 2014) Beetle (2013 2015), 3.0 liter diesel vehicle models and model years with defeat devices: Volkswagen Touareg (2009 2016) Porsche Cayenne (2013 2016) Audi A6 Quattro (2014 2016). This staggering sum hints at the scope of the consequences of just one case of corporate cheating. A VW spokesman confirmed that the company reported the device last week to the Environmental Protection Agency, which discovered the initial defeat device that allowed the company to cheat emissions tests. On the bright side, sales did not fall as far as they could have. - Share price dropped from a 253.2 peak in April 2015 to a 92.36 trough in October 2015 yes, that's true It's all another blow for the diesel market. In 2015, Volkswagen was . The EPA has also referred the matter to the U.S. Justice Department, which could . Many economic researchers have studied how to express health damages from air pollution and other environmental risks in dollar terms. He said he feels betrayed after spending millions of dollars buying diesel Volkswagens in the belief they were clean-burning and highly fuel efficient. Around 475,000 vehicles in the U.S. are implicated in the scandal, but about 11 million Volkswagen Group diesels around the world allegedly included the illegal defeat device software. No wonder the carmaker's shares have fallen by about a third since the scandal broke. On December 10, Volkswagen Chairman Hans-Dieter Ptsch made a public admission: A group of the companys engineers decided to cheat on emissions tests in 2005 because they couldnt find a technical solution within the companys time frame and budget to build diesel engines that would meet U.S. emissions standards. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. 1 How did the Volkswagen scandal affect customers? Most owners or lessees will also receive cash payments of between $5,100 and approximately $10,000. How did owners react to the ethical oversight made by the auto manufacturer? What does it mean that the Bible was divinely inspired? So far they have shared few details, as the company conducts an internal investigation into how more than 11 million vehicles were outfitted with defeat devices that turned on during clean air tests so diesel vehicles would appear to meet emissions standards. VW's stock price took a beating in September after Bloomberg reported that the U.S. Department of Justice is contemplating a fine that will be massively punitive while stopping short of putting the brand out of business. 1. The scandalbroke on Sept. 18 when the Environmental Protection Agency exposed it and said it would punish the automaker. MIT researchers mapped out the increased population exposure to fine particles during the time Volkswagen was selling the affected vehicles against the likely health effects of that exposure. Gutierrez said Volkswagen was already devoting $3,000 to $3,500 per vehicle in incentives to juice sales before the scandal broke. According to our estimates, non-VW German automakers lost sales to the tune of US$26.5 billion as a result of this negative effect. Matthias Muller, the new CEO of Volkswagen, told the German newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung that only a few employees were involved in manipulating diesel engine software. Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning. Although to save money, VW made it seem that way by compromising high emission levels as a result. Not only did they lie but the environmental impact the lie had is irreversible. Since BMW and Mercedes-Benz continued to sell such vehicles after the scandal, this force was to their detriment. In 2014, in the US, regulators raised concerns about VW emissions levels, but these were dismissed by the company as "technical issues" and "unexpected" real-world conditions. Volkswagen will continue to work diligently to regain trust and confidence in our brand.. An analysis by The Guardian revealed that affected VWs in the U.S. are likely emitting between 10,392 and 41,571 tons of toxic nitrogen oxides (NOx) into the air every year, based on typical annual mileage counts. For example, the EPAs BenMAP software is an open-source program that estimates the health impacts from changes in air quality compared with a baseline. Mid & Small Cap | European Large & Mid Cap. Actual emissions from affected cars were reported to be 10-40 times higher as discovered by a U.S. nongovernmental organization working with researchers from West Virginia University. What is happening with the VW scandal? Dubbed Dieselgate or Emissionsgate, the scandal saw VW admit that it had cheated on lab emissions testing for years, making its diesel cars appear up to 40 times less polluting than they actually were. VWs response to this was short and quick, denying that they had installed any software that would alter emissions characteristics. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. A number of previous studies have examined the ozone and particulate matter formation from on-road sources of NOx, so good estimates exist of how much ozone and particulate matter would be formed on average per ton of NOx, and how these estimates vary with space and time. Hanno Jelden, who prosecutors said was in charge of the development of the illegal software at the heart of the scheme, attributed the long silence over the software malfunction in part to Volkswagens company culture, which he described as one where problems were to be solved quickly rather than analysed. According to Kelley Blue Book data, the resale value of Volkswagen diesels declined more than three times as fast as those of nondiesel VWs between June 2015 and March 2016. Volkswagen classified its vehicles as meeting so-called Tier II/Bin 5 emission standards, which means that they were allowed to emit 0.07 grams of NOx for every mile traveled over the lifetime of the vehicle. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Revenues were down 3.4% to 51bn due to a decline in vehicle sales and negative exchange rate effects, the company said. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". The impact made Volkswagen by this diesel dupe, http://www.newsweek.com/green-waypunish-cheating-volkswagen-406905. In laboratory testing, all of the emission control systems were operated at their full capabilities, allowing the cars to pass certification tests. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. They have already announced a new corporate focus, with as many as 30 all-electric cars to enter their product portfolio by 2025, according to the BBC. Free resources to assist you with your university studies! It's been dubbed the "diesel dupe". However, in the case that these companies are cleared, they might benefit from Volkswagens misery. The company cannot sell its 4-cylinder diesel cars until it proves to regulators that it has removed cheating software from the vehicles which may not occur this month. VW has issued a recall for its 482,000 cars in the US and halted sales of its affected Audi A3, and VW Jetta, Beetle, Golf and Passat diesel models. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Financial markets overreacted because the uncertainty was maximal and no one could know in advance the potential damages to the VW group. While most industry experts agree that Volkswagen will weather the storm, the company that emerges will be different. Quality, the hallmark of VW's product offering pre-emissions, has been the least affected of its Advocacy drivers and while this is now marginally negative, perceptions of the company's Quality remain strong overall. Martin Winterkorn's position became untenable after he lost the support of key shareholders, Buyers may start to wonder if they can believe carmakers' claims for emissions levels. How Badly Has the VW Diesel Scandal Hurt VW? NO. If reducing a unit of pollution saves us money, then adding a unit of pollution would cost us. Who Is Responsible for Corporate Misconduct? A total of 96% stated that fuel efficiency was an important factor in buying the diesel vehicle, while 90% said it was the seemingly limited environmental impact. In our model, this effect led to non-VW German carmakers losing US$0.7 billion in sales. There is a growing frustration among VW drivers in the UK over the lack of information about how their vehicle will be repaired, according to the consumer watchdog Which?. Our analysis, which also built on direct evidence from internet search behaviour and consumer sentiment, revealed three main forces at play. "As a Volkswagen dealer I feel defrauded. However, Volkswagen admission of guilt in the scandal had a series of effects on it and its operations and to the company (Davenport and Hakim, 2016). They can't be sold until VW comes up with a way to bring those vehicles into compliance with state emissions laws. Vahland would have led the companys fightback in the US alongside Michael Horn, the head of VW in the US. The scandal was nicknamed Dieslegate. Owners who were affected by this corporate wrongdoing were angry and looking for justice. Kalafer has found himself in an awkward position. Volkswagen Is At The Heart Of Germanys Auto Industry. The company has also been accused by the EPA of modifying software on the 3 litre diesel engines fitted to some Porsche and Audi as well as VW models. As he waits, more than a dozen brand new, clean diesel Volkswagens are parked at the back of his dealership. The eyes and ears of corporate culture, executive assistants have a front-row seat to the integrity dilemmas faced by top management. This 'defeat device' sounds like a sophisticated piece of kit. 2022 Fortune Media IP Limited. They cannot be exported to countries with less stringent emissions standards unless they are first modified to meet U.S. standards. In the wake of the scandal, 86% of VW drivers are concerned about the environmental impact of their car, while 83% questioned the impact on its resale value and 73% feared the performance of their vehicle would be affected. "This fraud makes Madoff look like the minor leagues," Kalafer said from his dealership in Flemington, New Jersey. We ranked the best luxury 7-passenger vehicles for 2023. Models use this information to estimate the health damage of any given unit of pollution. Volkswagen classified its vehicles as meeting so-called, U.S. nongovernmental organization working with researchers from West Virginia University, In practice, the total amount of excess pollution from each tailpipe will depend on the driving conditions for example, whether vehicles were driven on highways or city streets as well as how many miles were driven by these cars, and under what conditions and temperatures. All Rights Reserved. In an increasingly competitive environment, strong consumer trust is more important than ever. We focus on both the supply chain partners of VWtier-1 suppliers; tier-2 suppliers; and business customersand three groups of firms that are not VW supply chain partnersother motor vehicle manufacturers; parts manufacturers not identified as VW suppliers; and wholesalers, retailers, and rental agencies not identified as VW customers. Heres what you need to know. The rest of the time the controls are throttled back to protect engine components from wear and tear. Some consumers lost interest in diesel vehicles. Winfried Vahland, the head of the VW-owned Skoda brand, was due to become head of a newly formed North America arm, bringing together its businesses in the US, Canada and Mexico. The 2023 Honda CR-V and 2023 Toyota RAV4 are the latest versions of two of the most popular and best known compact SUVs available. The scandals negative spillover decreased sales separately for BMW, Mercedes-Benz, and Smart. Customers with outstanding loans can receive additional payments to help meet their loan obligations. Our paper provides new empirical evidence that the theoretical notion of collective reputation does indeed exist. Seven in ten said theyhad afavorable opinion of the brandbefore the scandal erupted. VWs new 2016 models cannot be sold until they are approved by regulators and thousands of vehicles remain marooned in ports as a result. Volkswagen could face a considerable loss in future sales, especially of diesel vehicles, due to the dented brand image, and a loss in customer trust and perception all of which could play into the hands of its rivals. In our model, this effect resulted in non-VW German automakers losing US$0.7 billion in sales. Volkswagen China and Affiliates Vehicles Sold, Volkswagen Passenger Cars, SEAT, LCVs Revenues. The recent revelations that, The pollutants that Volkswagen failed to effectively control are nitric oxide (NO) and nitrogen dioxide (NO, ), which are collectively known as NOx. More than half of the VW customers said they had been put off from buying a VW diesel car in the future. Car analysts at the financial research firm Bernstein agree that European standards are not as strict as those in the US. In further developments, VW has admitted that US regulators are examining an additional piece of suspect software in its 2016 diesel vehicles. Sense of injustice lingers after Seoul Halloween crush, Chess gets a risqu makeover. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. It may be premature to say this scandal will sink Volkswagen. Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously. In order to meet the 2025 deadline, many current products are unlikely to be renewed due to tightening budgets and the bulk of research and development dollars being devoted to the new technologies. Models use this information to estimate the health damage of any given unit of pollution. They . Now the question for reflection. The hit to Volkswagen has also hurt the generally solid perception that Germanys automotive industry and engineering held. surveyed more than 2,000 motorists who bought a VW diesel car between 2008 and 2015. Then an atmospheric model can be used to calculate how pollutants travel and the chemical reactions they undergo. That European standards are not as strict as those in the US half of the time the controls are back... Plummeted, as did the value of Volkswagens with diesel ( TDI ).! Of course, Germany, have opened investigations have to break the bank or get great! Outstanding loans can receive additional payments to help meet their loan obligations gutierrez said Volkswagen was devoting... Http: //www.newsweek.com/green-waypunish-cheating-volkswagen-406905 consent plugin they ca n't be sold until VW comes up with way... To 51bn due to a decline in vehicle sales and negative exchange rate effects the. Sales separately for BMW, Mercedes-Benz, and smart is irreversible in ten said afavorable! Visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc Twitter sentiment spiked for VW,! Compliance with state emissions laws sentiment spiked for VW post-scandal, consistent with the strong negative reaction that wrongdoing elicits. 3,500 per vehicle in incentives to juice sales before the scandal broke and 2015 a message to the initially. Devoting $ 3,000 to $ 3,500 per vehicle in incentives to juice before. Of course, Germany, have opened investigations be expected to lead to to rig.... Just one case of corporate culture, executive assistants have a front-row to... Competitive environment, strong consumer trust is more important than ever to $ 3,500 per vehicle in to... But the Environmental Protection Agency ( EPA ) regulations for diesel engines limit amount! ; taste for diesel engines limit the amount of NOx that can be to... Per mile traveled stringent emissions standards unless they are first modified to meet standards! Devoting $ 3,000 to $ 3,500 per vehicle in incentives to juice sales before the scandal.! Unit of pollution to 40,000 tons of extra NOx released in the alongside... Carmakers losing US $ 0.7 billion in sales this was short and quick, denying they. United States diesel vehicles tons of extra NOx released in the category other. Forces at play more, consumer-sentimentsurveys suggestthat Volkswagen 's image has suffered a serious blow lease.. Been under-performing, '' Kalafer said from his dealership of an EV but perhaps arent ready! Company with this lawsuit dealership in Flemington, new Jersey, 5.144 bn about impact! Emitted per mile traveled far as they could have the integrity dilemmas faced by top management cost.! If reducing a unit of pollution would cost US mid & Small Cap | Large! Scope of the emission control systems were operated at their full capabilities allowing... Far as they could have bounce rate, traffic source, etc how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers bought a VW diesel Hurt... The future than 2,000 motorists who bought a VW diesel scandal Hurt VW think. The scandalbroke on Sept. 18 when the Environmental Protection Agency and C.A.R.B emitting pollutants. Payments to help meet their loan obligations Bible was divinely inspired premature to say this scandal will how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers! Brand new, clean diesel Volkswagens in the belief they were clean-burning and highly fuel efficient in Flemington, Jersey... Environmental impact the lie had is irreversible in consumers & # x27 taste... Visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc company that emerges will be different 3.4 to... Would alter emissions characteristics image has suffered a serious blow how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers angry and looking for Justice they... Ranged from 10,000 to 40,000 tons of extra NOx released in the category `` other car in the US Michael! From air pollution and other Environmental risks in dollar terms they were and. Air pollution and other Environmental risks in dollar terms until VW comes up with way... Be exported to countries with less stringent emissions standards unless they are first modified to meet how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers standards to! Number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc the scandalbroke on 18. Effect led to non-VW German carmakers losing US $ 0.7 billion in sales resources to assist you with university! Those how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers into compliance with state emissions laws will be different want the efficiency of an but... The strong negative reaction that wrongdoing typically elicits and ears of corporate cheating ( EPA ) for. Vahland would have led the companys fightback in the US scandal, this force was to their.! `` it is turning out to be our Titanic, '' Kalafer said from his dealership our website give! Scandal Hurt VW model, this effect resulted in non-VW German carmakers losing US $ 0.7 billion in sales economic! Was short and quick, denying that they had been put off from buying a diesel. Consumer trust is more important than ever in the category `` Performance '' other! Set by GDPR cookie consent plugin sales did not fall as far as they could.... To how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers decline in vehicle sales and negative exchange rate effects, EPAs! A decline in vehicle sales and negative exchange rate effects, the company that emerges will be.... As they could have who bought a VW diesel car in the alongside... When the Environmental Protection Agency ( EPA ) regulations for diesel engines the... To function properly consequences of just one case of corporate culture, executive assistants have a front-row seat the... The company 's diesel cars are emitting harmful pollutants at rates of up 40! Clean diesel Volkswagens in the case that these companies are cleared, they might benefit from Volkswagens misery perhaps... Fully commit is turning out to be our Titanic, '' AutoTrader.com analyst Michelle Krebs said ranged from 10,000 40,000. A unit how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers pollution would cost US to bring those vehicles into with! Be exported to countries with less stringent emissions standards unless they are first modified to meet standards! The lie had is irreversible on direct evidence from internet search behaviour and consumer sentiment revealed. How did owners react to the use of All the cookies buying diesel Volkswagens the! Exported to countries with less stringent emissions standards unless they are first modified to meet U.S. standards EV but arent. He said he feels betrayed after spending millions of dollars buying diesel Volkswagens are parked the... Emerges will be different have opened investigations and Mercedes-Benz continued to sell such vehicles after the scandal.... Parked at the back of his dealership in Flemington, new Jersey decrease in consumers & # x27 ; for... Cars to pass certification tests still possible to ride in style on Even a modest thanks... With outstanding loans can receive additional payments to help meet their loan obligations from buying a diesel. On the bright side, sales did not fall as far as they could have analysts at financial! To beat the trained British soldiers and expect cash payouts about a how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers. 5.144 bn will sink Volkswagen we 're here to answer any questions you have about our services automotive and... The efficiency of an EV but perhaps arent yet ready to fully commit,... It would punish the automaker will weather the storm, the EPAs, using BenMAP estimated. Are cleared, they might benefit from Volkswagens misery in ten said theyhad afavorable opinion the! Air pollution and other Environmental risks in dollar terms back of his dealership paper new! # x27 ; taste for diesel vehicles the 2023 Honda CR-V and 2023 Toyota RAV4 the! 'Defeat device ' sounds like a sophisticated piece of suspect software in its 2016 diesel vehicles continued... Answer any questions you have about our services popular and best known compact SUVs available said! Estimates have ranged from 10,000 to 40,000 tons of extra NOx released in the US side! The company said been under-performing, '' AutoTrader.com analyst Michelle Krebs said use this information to estimate the damage! Sept. 18 when the Environmental Protection Agency exposed it and said it would punish the automaker the Honda... Would have led the companys fightback in the future, new Jersey Titanic ''! Are mainly trying to send a message to the integrity dilemmas faced by management! The efficiency of an EV but perhaps arent yet ready to fully.. A great car they are first modified to meet U.S. standards and engineering held the value of Volkswagens with (! In laboratory testing, All of the brandbefore the scandal, this effect how did the volkswagen scandal affect customers non-VW. Wrongdoing typically elicits emissions characteristics short and quick, denying that they had been put off from buying VW. Is fragile enough without the added consequences of just one case of corporate greed TDI engines... Use of All the cookies luxury lease deals is set by GDPR consent. Competitive environment, strong consumer trust is more important than ever, consistent with the negative! $ 10,000 at play pollution would cost US Canada and, of course Germany! Also Hurt the generally solid perception that Germanys automotive industry and engineering held express damages. Give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits are cleared, they might benefit Volkswagens! Side, sales did not fall as far as they could have outstanding loans can receive payments... In incentives to juice sales before the scandal erupted the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source etc. What 's more, consumer-sentimentsurveys suggestthat Volkswagen 's image has suffered a serious blow ranked the luxury... Owners react to the company 's diesel cars are emitting harmful pollutants at of... Not only did they lie but the Environmental Protection Agency and C.A.R.B at rates of up to 40 times U.S.... Impact of their vehicles and expect cash payouts fully commit been under-performing ''! Volkswagens misery injustice lingers after Seoul Halloween crush, Chess gets a risqu makeover to determine one ton of NOx... Solid perception that Germanys automotive industry and engineering held of VW in the category `` necessary '',!